Top 10 Games That Will Grow On You

I’m often surprised by how a game that I initially don’t like has a way of winning me over after several plays. In fact, this happens quite a lot, and the only reason I’m even able to make such discoveries is because someone in my gaming group owns the game, likes it and keeps bringing it out.

It’s usually a game I’ve already written off as not for me, but because I’m sort of pressured into playing it, I have no choice but to make the best of it. Then, lo and behold, somewhere along the way I find myself actually looking forward to playing it!

This was originally going to be a Top 5 list, but as I was putting it together, I realized there were a lot of games that fit into this category. This whole “hate it at first and love it later” thing is quite real, and in some cases, games that I initially couldn’t stand have gone on to become some of my all-time favorites.

I suppose there’s a lesson in there somewhere about giving games a fair chance, but that’s a discussion for another day.

Let’s get into it!

10. It’s A Wonderful World

It’s the unique blend of card drafting and resource management that makes this one so replayable, but the first instinct after completely failing to get it after the first few times often results in people bouncing off of it. Take the time, it’s worth exploring.

When I first tried It’s A Wonderful World, my reaction was that it had a clever mechanic, but that was all it had. Essentially, the game’s theme was nothing more than the art on the cards. The game could have literally been about anything and still made sense.

More than that, the concept of drafting cards à la 7 Wonders felt very luck-driven. If you got a good spread of cards that allowed you to build an engine early, you were kind of set to score big, and if you didn’t, you were going to be left behind and stay there for the remainder of the game.

What I came to realize after many plays of this one is that while technically everything I originally thought about the game is mostly true, there is one caveat here. Once you get to know the cards in the deck, which does require a bit of memorization, you develop a sort of instinct for the odds of certain things showing up.

Almost like card counting in Blackjack, It’s A Wonderful World really rewards an intimate knowledge of the deck, and you get to a point where even though you don’t know exactly when certain cards will come up, you can build your strategy around the likelihood that they’ll show up at some point and you’ll get an opportunity to snag them.

It’s really a game about gambling on your knowledge of the deck and planning way ahead based on the cards you anticipate will come up later. Sort of like building a puzzle using pieces you have in your hand now and knowing that the missing ones will come along at some point and let you finish your puzzle.

It’s a pretty game, but it can be extremely frustrating. There is a lot of mental gymnastics in this one, and it doesn’t really ever go away. It’s a brain burner.

The interesting thing about this is that a card that might seem like a bad pick to someone who doesn’t know the game very well might be an absolute goldmine to someone who understands what it could potentially lead to. You start making decisions not just based on what’s in front of you, but on what you know is potentially coming down the road.

Once you get to this stage with the game, which admittedly takes much longer than it should for a game to make a good impression, It’s A Wonderful World really opens up, and you start to see the game from a very different perspective.

The result for me, at least, has been that even though I still find the game a bit frustrating at times, I do understand its nuanced brilliance. It’s actually an incredibly clever game design, very high-level and niche in a way that I think veteran board gamers will come to appreciate if they can get past that initial feeling that the game is kind of random.

This is a very thinky and very unique card-driven engine builder that, once you get it, is incredibly rewarding, especially if you enjoy a good mental exercise at the table.

It’s one of those games where the more you know about it, the less luck seems to have to do with it, and I think that’s ultimately what won me over.

9. Russian Railroads

The strange thing about Russian Railroads and I have said this many times, while the theme is “Railroads”, this is just a very involved and tricky worker placement game that could be about anything. The theme here is an indiscriminately chosen layer so that the game could have a cohesive art presentation, and that is all it is.

I think only people who have been reading my blog for years would know the full history and the range of emotions I’ve had about this game over the years. It remains one of my most contested and controversial reviews, one I bring up often.

My opinion on this one has swung back and forth many times, and I’ve been on both sides of the love it or hate it fence at different points over the years.

The reality, however, is that Russian Railroads really is a very robust, very intriguing game, and I think worker placement fans who enjoy really diving into the nuances of a complex and highly competitive Euro game are probably going to love this one.

I will say that I think some aspects of this game are a bit scripted, and that’s kind of one of my beefs with it. In fact, it reminds me a lot of the issues I have with Puerto Rico as well.

There are times and situations that come up during play where your decision is effectively made for you. You have this sort of situation where if option A or B is available, you have to take it or you’re going to lose the game. For example, anytime you have an opportunity to take coins, you MUST do so. Just about any other move is a bad move regardless of the situation.

Russian Railroads has a lot of tracks, both shared and personal. There are tons of different ways to score points and countless possible strategies that can create ridiculous results. Simultaneously, there is a lot of stuff here that borders on useless, and it takes many plays of the game to distinguish the difference between the two.

Games that force play in a scripted fashion like this really irk me. They sort of rub against my need for a game to be fully dynamic, where there are many viable roads to victory and the success of a strategy is more a matter of how well you execute it than which strategy you choose.

Russian Railroads has a few routes that simply don’t win games, so they sort of exist to be ignored, and that bothers me. The truth, however, is that there’s plenty of game here, more than you’ll initially realize, to turn this sometimes scripted worker placement game into a truly competitive and tight experience.

It’s a game of efficiency, good long term strategic planning and some very rewarding risk versus reward plays. It’s a game of spotting opportunities not just on the current turn, but two, three, four or even five turns ahead. It’s almost like chess, where someone makes a move and you can see how in four moves you’re going to checkmate them, and your opponent won’t even know what a big mistake they just made until then.

It can be very satisfying, and it takes quite a bit of intricate mastery to really discover the depths of this one. This is a game where the difference in end game scoring between a master and a relatively experienced novice can be 200 points. There are huge skill gaps possible, so you definitely want to be playing with people close to your skill level, as the differences in skill and depth of understanding can be quite dramatic.

I think what’s changed for me over the years is that I’ve come to appreciate just how much room there is for clever play within what I once considered a fairly rigid game. I still have some of the same issues with it that I always did, but they bother me a lot less now that I’ve discovered how much there is to explore.

Ultimately, Russian Railroads is a bit of a hidden gem, one that can be hard to dig up, but if you find that magic, it’s actually an incredibly challenging and fun game. It has certainly earned its place on this list.

8. Sid Meier’s Civilization: The Board Game

It’s imperfect as a board game, but as an adaptation of Sid Meier’s Civilization PC game, it get’s a lot right. In a way, it is exactly what it’s supposed to be, a game for fans.

This 2010 release was one I had mixed feelings about when it first arrived. On the one hand, it was a very exciting release. I’m a huge Civilization fan, this was a Fantasy Flight Games release, one of my favorite companies at the time, responsible for some of my favorite games of all time, and on top of that, it was a Kevin Wilson design, the guy behind some of the coolest projects FFG ever produced. From Fury of Dracula and Descent to Android and lesser known titles like Arena Maximus.

Suffice it to say, the hype and expectations for this one were through the roof for me, and truth be told, while I thought the game was clever and interesting, I found some aspects of it to be a bit disappointing.

I especially didn’t like the rock, paper, scissors approach to combat, there were some very clear balance issues with the original release so far as the civilizations went, and there were also some quirky elements to the resource management that didn’t feel quite right to me.

All in all, I didn’t hate it, but it just didn’t “do it” for me in the way I had hoped, and ultimately the game sort of faded from the table. I think I ended up playing it two or three times before I bounced off it.

Fast forward a few years later, I had an opportunity to play this one again and I took a shot at it. I still think there’s a lot of truth to my original assessment of this game. In fact, I stand by what I said in my Top 5 Games That Were Almost Great list when I said that the number one complaint from people who play it is “Great game, terrible combat mechanics.”

The combat mechanics are a chore that can be worked around. There is so much else going on in this game that is worth your attention and very well worth exploring and you won’t discover it on your first few plays. There is a deeper, more connected experience to the source material in this one of many attempts over the years to capture the PC game.

That said, I do think the combat system has a sort of arms race thing going for it where, if one player upgrades their combat ability and everyone else follows suit, the impact of combat on the game’s outcome becomes almost irrelevant. It’s only when someone gets properly ahead in military tech that the game starts to feel very oppressive and the nature of the combat mechanic being so deterministic becomes a problem.

When everyone at the table understands this, the rest of the game can actually be quite interesting. There’s a sort of balance of power that develops at the table, and as long as everyone keeps an eye on what everyone else is doing, the military aspect of the game becomes more about keeping each other in check than actually fighting.

It still, in my opinion, gets shown up by a lot of the civilization-building games that followed, including games like Clash of Cultures, Through the Ages (2nd edition) and most recently Epochs, but I do think this game has a lot going for it and definitely deserves better than becoming a permanent dust collector.

There are a lot of really clever mechanics, the game remains very competitive, but the biggest thing it does, which I feel a lot of games miss, is capture that feeling of a growing civilization expanding across a map that makes the whole concept of a Civilization game so intriguing.

There is something very satisfying about starting with a single city, exploring the world around you, discovering new technologies, expanding your civilization and watching it all come together. It’s a feeling that a lot of civilization-building games abstract away in favor of other mechanics, but here it’s very much a part of the experience.

In a word, I think it captures the feeling of playing the video game better than any other Civilization board game you’ll ever play.

I think part of what changed for me over the years is that I stopped looking at this game in terms of what I wished it was and started appreciating it for what it actually does really well. The combat mechanic still isn’t my cup of tea, but there is a whole lot more to this game than its combat system.

So it might not be the best “civilization building” game out there, but I think it’s certainly the best board game adaptation of Sid Meier’s Civilization, and that alone makes it a worthy addition to this list.

It’s worth noting as well that FFG listened to a lot of the feedback on this game and addressed the combat mechanic complaints in some of the expansions, I haven’t tried them, but my understanding is that it addresses this issue in a very inventive and definitive way, so that is also something I hope to try at some point in the future.

7. Cascadia

Cascadia is a gloriously simple game, but it’s not just the simplicity that makes it such an easy sell to pretty much anyone, it’s a combination of its theme and familiar gaming concepts that just feel natural and intuitive. Even the first play feels familiar.

Cascadia is not exactly a big comeback story. In fact, I still think it’s kind of a meh game, but the thing I realized after a few disappointing plays and coming back to it is just how perfect of a design it is.

That may seem like a strange reason to put this one on the list, as my opinion of it as a personal gaming experience hasn’t changed all that much, but for me, discovering board games isn’t always about personal preferences. Sometimes you spot a game that seems to click with a particular group or type of gamer, and having that game in your back pocket can create some really nice experiences.

What I love about Cascadia as a game design is that it lands so well with non-gamers. This is the sort of game that wives and grandmas enjoy. It has that Gin Rummy or Checkers kind of thing going for it, where it’s almost like an old-time classic that anyone can understand, and it triggers some part of the non-gamer’s brain that leaves them wanting to play it again and again.

It’s a strange kind of thing that happens when you transition from a non-gamer to a gamer, you sort of lose your ability to see complexity and depth as an obstacle, but non-gamers, they see most games and think “holy crap, it looks complicated”. The reality doesn’t matter that perception is enough for most people to bounce off of a game. Cascadia sort of get’s that, it does not look complicated, and it never becomes so.

I can say this about very few games and have it be true, but Cascadia is a universally playable game. Anywhere, anytime, with anyone, it always sticks the landing, and that’s a powerful and unique ability that 99% of the games on my hobby shelves simply don’t have. Most games have a niche or an intended audience, whether it’s because of the theme, gameplay or what have you.

Cascadia is truly universal, and the thing that happens at the table with this game is that anyone, quite literally anyone, can be competitive after a single play. The mechanics rely on natural human instincts for pattern recognition and organization, not on “board gaming skill.” It’s a game of intuition, and it’s just pleasant and fun to watch that play out.

These days, whenever I’m unsure what game to pull out with a particular mix of players, the answer is almost always Cascadia. It’s like a weird magical solution that never fails you.

And the more I play this game, the more it grows on me. I mean, originally I just thought it was a silly, puzzly introductory-style game, but there is depth here, there is strategy, and while there are ways to expand on the game, I still think the original is the best way to experience this one.

It’s a sort of modern-day classic with a strange nostalgic feel to it, even if it’s the first time you play it, almost like it’s an old familiar friend.

I think what I’ve come to appreciate about Cascadia is that a game doesn’t have to be one of my favorite games to be one of the most valuable games in my collection. There is something quite special about a game that can bring just about anyone to the table and have everyone walk away wanting to play it again.

Great game, definitely earns its place on this list.

6. The Castles Of Burgundy

Dice-driven games, especially ones that drive your action economy I used to think very little off, but once you get to know some of these games like Castles of Burgundy, you gain a sort of appreciation for the mechanic. I don’t know why exactly, but it doesn’t have to make logical sense, it can be enough that you s

I remember very clearly when The Castles of Burgundy first came out about 15 years ago, and after my first play of it, I thought to myself, yeah, it’s a bit like Settlers of Catan. A dice-based Euro where winning or losing ultimately boils down to the luck of the dice.

Now, to be fair, I don’t think this is even necessarily true about Settlers of Catan, and it certainly wasn’t true about The Castles of Burgundy, but I had a chip on my shoulder when it came to dice-based resource generation or dice-based action mechanics. I was, for a very long time, a big believer that deterministic mechanics and “good mechanics” were the same thing.

I didn’t think much of Burgundy back then, and it would be well over 10 years before I would end up playing this game again, thanks to the digital version found on BoardGameArena.com and some online friends who reintroduced it to me.

I played it once, twice, three times. Before I knew it, the game clicked for me, and I found myself not only requesting it but diving deep into its nuanced mechanics and strategies.

What I came to realize is that the dice in The Castles of Burgundy aren’t really there to determine whether or not you succeed, they’re there to present you with a set of circumstances that you have to figure out how to make the most of. There are so many ways to mitigate the luck of the dice, so many clever ways to get things done, and the better you get at the game, the more you realize just how much control you actually have over your own destiny.

The Castles of Burgundy has a lot going on, with plenty of special buildings, methods of scoring, and unique ways everything can combo. There are so many different strategies and ways to win, and none of it is held back in any significant way because of the dice. They force you to be a bit more flexible and dynamic with your strategy, and certainly sometimes you get the worst dice or best dice possible that can make things easier or harder, but you are never really prevented from pursuing any given strategy.

It’s kind of funny that the very thing that put me off this game initially is now one of the things I appreciate most about it. Having to adapt your plans to what the dice give you is a big part of what makes the game so interesting, and it’s a testament to just how clever the design is.

This game is a classic for a reason. It’s actually quite outstanding, and even though it took more than a decade for it to change my mind, I’m a bona fide convert. I love this game, it’s got the nuts, and I’m happy to play it anytime.

5. Dewan

Dewan is a great example of modern game design. It’s streamlined and tight to perfection.

While I thought Dewan was an interesting and ultimately good game even when I first tried it, I saw all of its strengths through very academic eyes. To me, it was a very strong design with a lot of clever mechanics, but after playing it a couple of times, I was sort of done with it.

I didn’t feel that spark of interest that goes beyond the evaluative approach to a game I often have to take when I’m doing a review. The game reviewed well, it certainly had my stamp of approval as a reviewer, but it was immediately placed on the cull pile. I had no intention of keeping it.

There was one problem with my plan, however, and that was that some of the people I’d played this game with liked it and requested to play it again after my decision was made. I hadn’t physically culled the game yet, and when someone asks to play a game again, I tend to be pretty agreeable and accommodating. After all, the whole point of introducing all these games I review to friends and family is to spark an interest in them, so if someone has such an interest, I say, let’s play!

The artwork in Dewan is captivating, original and surreal in a wonderful, eye-popping blend that deserves to be celebrated. AI is put on notice here because whatever you think about AI art, it’s never going to be this good.

So we played it, once, twice, three times. Before I knew it, I was playing Dewan a whole lot more often than I ever thought I would, and I started to discover a lot of nuanced depth to the game, in particular in how competitive it became.

I still stand by my review, but the truth is that I ended up liking this game a lot more the more I played it, and it ultimately found a permanent home in my collection.

I think a lot of it stems from the fact that while the rules of the game are simple and the scoring is very tight, it’s the dynamic nature of all the interaction between the players that really pushes this one over the top for me.

This is a very competitive game once everyone knows how to play it well, and it becomes an almost sport-like event. While there is some luck involved in the card draw, this luck is more like the effects of weather on a football game, some might argue it’s an advantage for one team or the other but it’s more of an impression than a reality. For the most part, it’s a very deterministic game, and skill plays a very significant role in determining who wins. In a group where everyone knows what they’re doing, games are typically won and lost by no more than a couple of points.

It’s one of those games where the better everyone gets at playing it, the more interesting the game becomes, and I think that’s something I completely missed in those first couple of plays. It’s an almost pessimistic thing that happens when you review games as a weekly thing where you start to feel like two or three plays are typically enough to judge a game. Sometimes you miss how mastery of a game can change your perception of it.

Very replayable, very tight, and a game that I think anyone who enjoys that competitive, interactive style of Euro without any “take that” mechanics would appreciate. This really is a game of skill and clever execution, and as it turns out, exactly the sort of game I want to have in my collection.

4. Path Of Civilization: A Story Of Humankind

It’s both a complex system and architecture, while being a relatively straightforward game mechanically. It’s a game of efficiency and timing, but it’s short, so your plans need to be quite focused on the “right now,” which is sort of opposite to the instinct you will have the first few games. You need to always be scoring points.

I went through three stages when it came to Path of Civilization. Initially, I was excited, as I typically love a good civilization-building game. Lord knows there are plenty on my shelf, from Through the Ages, Western Empires and Nations to the sci-fi stuff like Arcs, Twilight Imperium and Eclipse.

That excitement soured immediately after my first and even my second play of this one. Path of Civilization, while a relatively quick game utilizing simultaneous actions, suffers from iconography overkill. It’s a very hard game to get your head around, with tons of keywords represented by icons that you have to remember, lots of interacting concepts and mechanics, and a turn sequence with a strict order of operations that’s very hard to follow.

Once it all clicks, which took me several plays, what you discover, however, is that this game… has the nuts, as one might say.

There is a tremendous amount of interaction between the different tracks you climb based on which four cards you put into play each round. You never have enough juice in these cards to do even a quarter of what you want, so the game is all about squeezing as much benefit out of your decisions as possible, finding synergies that will give you even more benefits later. Ultimately, you’re trying to come out on top on as many tracks, succeed in as many challenges and pick up as many points as you can along the way.

I think I spent the first half dozen games completely confused about the cause and effect of different actions and resources. The way the scoring works is also a bit mischievous; you can’t be a master of a single thing and hope to win, you need to outscore or at least keep up with everyone in every area.

There are so many different options and routes to take, and understanding the intricacies of that order of operations is absolutely the key to success.

In a way, the game feels like you have virtually no control when you first try it. Stuff is happening, and it takes quite a bit of understanding of the mechanics to figure out how and why. What I initially perceived as a lack of control turned out to be quite the opposite. Once you understand how all the pieces fit together, you realize just how much control you actually have.

I have to say, though, once it clicks, not only is this a very deep and meaningful game with a lot of important decisions to be made, but it’s also incredibly tight and competitive. It’s a race, and a short one at that. You don’t have a lot of time to get everything you want or need to get done, so just about every decision involves some sort of sacrifice.

The whole thing boils down to timing and being as efficient as you can possibly be, and it’s all very deterministic. There is virtually no luck in the game at all.

I’m very impressed with Path of Civilization at this point. It took time to really click for me, but I’m sold. It’s excellent in that slow-burn kind of way, and had I gone with my instincts after those first couple of plays, I would’ve missed out on a really great game.

3. Tapestry

Tapestry has levels of depth and mastery that will challenge even the most veteran of boardgamers, but this is not immediately apparent and I find a lot of people who should love this game bounce off it. You really have to spend some time with it to really “get it” and that means playing through some potentially frustrating matches.

I will admit that I had an immediate affection for Tapestry, but I ultimately didn’t want to play it because I found it really hard to “get into.”

Not sure that makes sense, but some games have a gameplay loop that’s difficult to get your head around, and Tapestry, while on the surface is mechanically simple, is actually an incredibly robust and complex game from a gameplay perspective.

It’s so nuanced, and nothing works quite like you think it should or would based on the rules explanation. The resource management in particular is so strange, and the experience of playing with someone who has figured it out while you’re still struggling with it is daunting.

You see people start with four resources and turn that into a round where they’re doing a dozen things and still have resources remaining, and you’re sort of left scratching your head wondering how the hell they did that much with so little.

In fact, when playing against someone who knows what they’re doing, they’ll sometimes have scored twice as many points by the end of their second round as you’ll score by the end of your second game combined. Yeah, it’s that big. I’ve seen people score 250+ points, and I’ve seen new players barely break 50.

The skill gap in this game is huge, and it takes quite a few plays to really connect the dots and understand the very nuanced way the action economy and resource economy work. However, once you get it, this game becomes incredibly competitive and offers a huge array of strategic options and a tremendous amount of depth.

Tapestry is an amazing game, but I will say that I don’t like introducing it to new people, and I don’t particularly like playing with new people either, because it’s not a game where the strategy is easy to explain. People just have to go through several games and get to those “aha” moments on their own. Trying to help them get there can actually make the experience that much more confusing for them. It hinders rather than helps to explain it. You give them the rules and let them start making discoveries, that rather painful teaching method works best.

That, however, means you might have to play against some really inexperienced opponents who are going to be frustrated for a couple of games before things start to click into place. More than that, it takes dozens of plays before you get even close to the scores of expert players because there are so many nuanced levels of skill, little tricks, and unique approaches to the game.

Tapestry is big and stunning in person, but it’s a pretty long game. While I think the boardgamearena.com digital version is a great place to learn how to play this one, it’s definitely a game made for the table.

The really cool thing about Tapestry is that once you start to understand how all these things work together, you start seeing opportunities everywhere. The same four resources that once seemed barely enough to do anything suddenly represent all sorts of possibilities. You start thinking about what one action can lead to, what that next action can get you and how you can squeeze just a little bit more out of everything you do.

It’s just a really tough game to learn to play well, and that may actually be why so many people bounce off of it, but I assure you, once it clicks for you, the game is incredibly rewarding and very challenging when playing against people who “get it.”

I love this game. At this point, it graces several of my Top X lists, and for good reason. It’s a really wonderfully designed gamer’s game that rewards commitment to learning its unique, nuanced gameplay.

It’s kind of ironic that a game with such a simple set of rules has turned out to be one of the most difficult games in my collection to master, but that’s a big part of what keeps me coming back to it.

2. Advanced Civilization (Western Empires)

Advanced Civilization (aka Western Empires as it’s known today) is a bona fide classic and the ultimate dust collector. Getting it to the table is no small feat, but if you can manage it, it’s an unmatched gaming experience.

My history with this game is long and turbulent, and though my gut feeling is that I’ve actually always loved it, there is no question that we’ve had a few breakups over the years.

In my eyes, the biggest challenge with Advanced Civilization, known as Western Empires these days, is simply getting it to the table. It’s an infinitely challenging task, requiring a level of dedication from a fairly large group of people that is almost impossible to coordinate. This is made even more difficult if there is even a single person in the group who finds themselves not enjoying the game partway through.

Suffice it to say, Western Empires is difficult to get to the table, and the experience can be absolutely ruined, and often is, by a single player who isn’t really into it.

And so, while I love the game with all my heart, in nearly 20 years I can count on one hand the number of times I’ve managed to get it to the table, and I would say perhaps one in five times you actually have a great experience with everyone fully on board.

That is a poor track record indeed.

Yet despite it all, one thing I can say with certainty is that when this game makes you a fan, it’s for life. I’ve known many gamers in my day, and over the years there is one game that consistently comes up in conversations about the all-time greats, and that is Advanced Civilization (Western Empires).

It’s a game I’m always holding out hope for, despite it being a dust collector the overwhelming majority of the time. Every now and then, the stars align, you get the right group of people together, everyone is committed to the experience, and you remember exactly why you’ve been hanging on to this monster of a game for all these years.

Because it’s not just a game, it truly is an experience. A white elephant in the wild, which, if you know, you know.

The biggest hurdle is the required player count. At an absolute minimum, you need 5 players, and realistically you want at least 7 or 8, with a maximum of 9 players being preferable. Even if you manage to gather a group of appropriate size, you will need about 12-18 hours to finish a game, and that is assuming you are hitting it hard and using timers for the trade phase to keep things moving.

I suppose that’s the strange relationship I have with Western Empires. It’s a game that has frustrated me more times than I care to remember, a game I’ve occasionally sworn I’d never bother trying to organize again, yet one that I would jump at the opportunity to play tomorrow if the right group came along.

For that reason, it definitely belongs on this list. I know it’s not going to be for everyone, but for true aficionados of gaming out there, this is a true, genuine gem.

1. Lord Of The Rings: The Living Card Game

It’s a fine coop game, but the truth is that Lord Of The Rings: The Living Card Game is one of the best solo games ever made. It takes a fair amount of time, dedication and money to get the most out of it, as you will definitely want to collect everything you can get your hands on, but the game experience is unmatched, especially if you are a Lord Of The Rings fan.

There is no question that this is one of my favorite comeback stories and perhaps the best example of why you should always give games a second and third chance before giving up on them.

A friend of mine introduced this one to me a long time ago, and despite being a huge Lord of the Rings fan, after playing it a couple of times, I thought the game was boring and random. It didn’t speak to me at all.

As is often the case, however, I ended up playing it a few more times to appease my friend who was really into it, and man, am I glad I did.

Lord of the Rings: The Living Card Game has gone from being a hard pass for me after the first few times I tried it to becoming one of my all-time favorite games. It’s been swimming at or near the top of my best of lists for years, I’ve effectively collected everything that’s ever been printed for it, and I’ve even gone above and beyond by pimping out my components and game area. I love it that much.

How did it happen? Well, I think the turning point for me was when I realized that while the core set introductory adventures were a bit weak, the expansion sets were something else altogether. In fact, I still think this is kind of a problem with this game. The core set adventures are a weird mix of way too easy and seemingly impossible, and they really don’t do a great job of showcasing just how good this game can be.

More importantly, though, I discovered what an amazing solo game this is. In fact, this is my preferred way to play Lord of the Rings: The Living Card Game. It’s like a self-contained hobby where you can experience the full range of what this game has to offer on your own, anytime you like, and it’s every bit as good solo as it is with a partner or group.

When they released the Lord of the Rings Saga expansions, which effectively link together into a single massive campaign that takes you through the entire trilogy, that’s when the game really just exploded for me.

The collection aspect of this game is addictive; no matter how much you have, you always want more. The nice things about the game, however is that it’s not a CCG, it’s based on the Living Card Game concept from FFG, which basically means that when you buy an expansion, you get everything you need. You never have to go searching for cards with random boosters or anything like that. You just buy the sets you want, and you know what cards you’re getting when you buy.

That campaign mode is so much fun, so challenging and so incredibly addictive that as of this writing, I must have attempted to play through the entire thing dozens of times over the years, and to this day, I shit you not, I’ve never successfully beaten the campaign.

The funny thing is that this hasn’t diminished my enthusiasm for the game one bit. If anything, it’s part of what keeps me coming back to it.

The game has an incredibly challenging level of difficulty. You have to be a very good deck builder, you really need to know this game intimately to do well, and to beat that campaign, you have to play exceptionally well. There is always something new to try, some new deck to build, some clever combination of cards to discover, and of course, that elusive campaign victory to chase.

It’s kind of ironic that a game I initially dismissed as boring and random has turned into a game that I’ve spent years trying to master and still haven’t managed to conquer.

I adore this game. It has been and remains one of the best games on the market today, in my opinion, and I shudder to think that had it not been for a friend who insisted we play it a few more times, I might never have discovered just how amazing it is.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *