Tag Archives: Boardgame Review

Review: Magical Athlete (2025)

Magical Athlete, originally released in 2003, is a wacky roll-and-move racing game that gets a fresh reprint in 2025. The sales pitch is that Magical Athlete is a “racing party game of pure chaos”, targeting a wide audience and giving a generous nod to the party game genre.

I want to get something out of the way right from the start so there’s no confusion about my feelings on this. When it comes to board gaming, while there are plenty of successful games built around the simple roll-and-move mechanic, I consider it, and I think there’s a fair bit of consensus on this, to be one of the least interesting mechanics and gameplay loops in all of gaming.

There’s just something inherently boring about rolling a die, moving a few spaces and calling that a game. It reminds me of games I haven’t played since I was a kid, and for good reason, like Sorry!, Chutes and Ladders and Parcheesi.

There are exceptions, of course. Classics like Talisman and Formula D are great examples of games that have managed to take this incredibly basic concept and turn it into something genuinely entertaining, even beloved. But to borrow a phrase from modern internet lingo, generally speaking, the whole roll-and-move mechanic gives me the ick!

A racing game where you chuck dice and move is a gaming concept as old as time, and frankly, most of the time these sorts of games are terrible, but there are exceptions to the rules. Formula D for example, is amazing, truly!

Magical Athlete is attempting to be one of those exceptions, following in the footsteps of games like Formula D by taking a mechanic I (and arguably most) generally doesn’t sound exciting and somehow making it fun.

Did it succeed? Let’s find out.

Overview

Final Score: christmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_star(4.2 out of 5) Surprisingly Great Party Game

The Magical Athlete reprint is a considerable visual improvement over the original. I say that, based purely on pictures I have seen online, I’ve never actually played the first print. This new version is bright, colorful and features a clever, appealing art style backed by some really nice components.

This is important, perhaps more important for Magical Athlete than for most games, because the reality is that for all its efforts to be a fun, chaotic racing game, mechanically speaking, there really isn’t much going on here beyond the roll-and-move roots this game is founded on.

Having never played the original, I can’t say whether the game has changed in any significant way, it appears there are considerably more characters, but what we have here mechanically is, let’s just say, a very minimalist approach to game design.

The original Magical Athlete looks like a prototype, yet despite appearances, this game has a dedicated cult following. The reprint is actually a highly anticipated event.

The game itself is incredibly straightforward. You start by drafting characters that will represent your racing team in the upcoming races. These wonderfully bizarre creatures really are the stars of the show. You’ve got ridiculous characters like The Banana, Cheerleader, Egg and a strange house with legs called Baba-Yaga, just to name a few. All with thematically on-point special abilities.

Each racer’s special ability activates during play, giving them some unique advantage designed to help them win the race. This, however, has a much higher-level purpose because, while these are mechanical gadgets that trigger as part of a game you’re trying to win, they are sort of the comedic juice that establishes Magical Athlete as a chaotic, let’s roll some dice to see what funny stuff happens party game.

The new edition of Magical Athlete is bright, colorful, and cannot possibly be described with a more enthusiastic “it’s weird”.

These powers create the silly moments, the stuff people are going to laugh about and remember. They are, in a word, the reason to play. Mechanically, it’s not something you are going to analyze, scrutinize and make part of some sort of strategic decision to help you win the game. It is, just as it appears, a silly game that offers an opportunity to be silly with your friends for the sake of silliness alone.

The rest of the game is considerably simpler than even this rather basic drafting setup. Each race consists of players taking turns rolling a six-sided die, moving along a racetrack with features like move 2 spaces forward or trip and fall, while hoping against hope to trigger their character’s special powers to execute the chaos and create the laughs. Whoever reaches the finish line first scores some points.

The completely ridiculous characters double down on the game’s whimsy by having outrageous powers. They are definitely the stars of the show.

Do this better than everyone else over the course of four races and you win the game.

There’s something undeniably charming about a very simple, funny-looking game that doesn’t take itself seriously in any way, shape or form. It’s just a zany little thing you can do with your friends, and sometimes that’s all a game really needs to be.

The wackier your friends are, the more likely Magical Athlete is going to work at your table, which arguably is a true statement about all tabletop games, I suppose.

Components

Score: christmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_star
Tilt: christmas_starchristmas_star

Pros: Wonderfully eccentric retro artwork, vibrant colors, quality components and a huge cast of bizarre, memorable characters. The entire presentation oozes personality.

Cons: The gameboard is rather plain and underwhelming compared to the wonderfully imaginative character artwork.

I think the most wonderful aspect of Magical Athlete is that the designers and publishers understood that, given the game’s simplicity, the visual presentation needed to be something unique. Something special.

Everything about this game’s component presentation is as much a sales pitch as it is an important part of the identity it wants to establish.

From the box art to opening the box, this game’s components lean into the sales pitch. Wacky and chaotic is promised, and wacky and chaotic is what you are going to get.

Even the box art has this subtle nuance to it, looking like something that could easily be mistaken for a game released back in the 60s. There is a very conscious effort to make Magical Athlete visually memorable, the sort of game that makes you say things like “cool” and “weird”, which, very unironically, is exactly how I would describe it.

The gameboard, taking up very little table real estate, has a distinctly retro look, with a color palette reminiscent of old British cartoons.

The cards follow suit, all nicely cut and finished, designed to last, with each one more vivid and curious than the last. There’s something about the artwork that invites the same sort of fascinated inspection you might give a 70s Queen album cover. It’s all wonderfully clever and unique, inspiring exactly the kind of excitement you want to feel when unboxing a game and laying everything out on the table for the first time.

The many wooden characters representing the racers on the board are equally bright and colorful, easy to identify and nicely matched to their card counterparts.

The game comes with tons of characters, and there are already expansions that double and triple the character count. Each one is more ridiculous than the next.

Everything in this package has a strange and curious kind of appeal. It’s all deliberately designed to get you into the mood for the wacky racing game that’s about to unfold, and in that regard, I think Magical Athlete absolutely nails it.

Theme

Score: christmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_star
Tilt: christmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_star

Pros: Wonderfully bizarre retro theme bursting with personality, clever Easter eggs and imaginative character abilities that bring the cartoon chaos to life. An unexpectedly charming and cohesive experience.

Cons: The theme is largely carried by the artwork and character abilities, with little thematic depth beyond the wacky racing premise.

Magical Athlete definitely has a theme, if a strange 70s retro cartoon vibe featuring incomprehensible characters having a foot race constitutes a theme. It’s a bit like some bizarre fever dream version of the World Olympics.

The color palettes of 60s and 70s cartoons were wonderfully bizarre, seemingly without rhyme or reason, yet somehow they worked. Magical Athlete unmistakably borrows from this peculiar aesthetic, giving it an oddly nostalgic charm, like something you vaguely remember from childhood but can’t quite place.

The artwork populating this game and its bright, strangely disorganized color palette are what give Magical Athlete its rather neurotic personality.

The game itself, being such a simple, luck-based dice roller, is essentially brought to life by the barminess of its theme, primarily through the cards representing the bizarre contestants.

The character powers themselves are probably the only real mechanical connection to the theme, but if wacky and chaotic was the goal, dare I say, mission accomplished.

There are some clever historical and mythological Easter eggs, like Sisyphus from Greek mythology, who was punished by the gods and condemned to spend eternity pushing an enormous boulder up a hill, only for it to roll back down every time he approached the summit. The card cleverly plays on this punishment with a mechanic that sends him warping back to the starting line whenever he rolls a six. I don’t know who this easter egg is for, but the game is kind of filled with these sort of academic surprises, giving it a bit of intelligence hidden in the absurdity.

I love easter eggs and quirky things like this in games!

Then you have even more chaotic characters like Flip Flop, who can skip rolling the die altogether and instead swap places with another racer, potentially turning the entire race on its head in a single turn. Big effects like this are standard operating procedure for this game.

Suffice it to say, each power seems stranger than the next, and these abilities can have a real impact on the race. The drafting round, when you’re picking your racers, is where you formulate a plan for the races ahead. Not that this gives you much actual control over the outcome, but there is definitely a bit more to Magical Athlete than simply rolling a die and moving along a track.

That little bit of extra something is the main connection to the theme, or at least the theme’s attempt to recreate the sort of ridiculous, unpredictable chaos you might expect from an old Saturday morning cartoon.

I wouldn’t really expect a theme like this to work, but, strangely enough, it all translates into a kind of fun, silly activity. In fact, I think it’s the theme more than anything else that manages to sell the whole experience when you first get it to the table.

So, yeah, it works.

Gameplay

Score: christmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_star
Tilt: christmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_star

Pros: Outrageously chaotic character abilities create hilarious, unpredictable races and plenty of memorable moments. Simple, accessible and surprisingly entertaining with the right crowd.

Cons: Mechanically shallow, almost entirely luck-driven and offers very little meaningful decision-making. Heavily dependent on player count and the atmosphere around the table to deliver its magic.

The gameplay in Magical Athlete can be largely explained by asking whether you’ve ever played a game like Chutes and Ladders or Sorry!, because mechanically speaking, that’s pretty much what you’re getting here.

That explanation, however, doesn’t really capture the experience. It more accurately describes the core mechanic, which, when spelled out in a review like this, sounds about as exciting as watching paint dry. And frankly, it would be, if that really was the entire experience.

Roll a die, move your character, rinse and repeat. Riveting stuff!

The thing about Magical Athlete is that it somehow manages to exist beyond the limitations of its own mechanics. There’s a sort of higher function to the gameplay loop here, something that has very little to do with strategy, decision-making, or even the game itself. It’s much closer to a party game or a silly social activity than anything resembling a traditional board game, and much of the heavy lifting comes from the aptly advertised “chaotic race”, an effect produced almost entirely by the bizarre special powers of the characters.

It reminds me a great deal of Galaxy Truckers, even though these two games have very little in common mechanically, the atmosphere and emotional payoff at the table can be remarkably similar.

Galaxy Trucker is nonsense in a box, yet remains one of my all-time favorites in what I like to call “silly activity” genre of games. You frantically build a ship from random components and then put your ship through an obstacle course of disasters that tear it apart, hoping to survive long enough to score points. It barely qualifies as a game, yet it’s a ridiculous amount of fun.

It’s that wonderful sort of gaming chaos where everything is going horribly wrong, nobody can quite believe what just happened and the entire table erupts into laughter at the tomfoolery of it all. The difference, of course, is that Galaxy Trucker gives you considerably more agency in creating your own disasters, while Magical Athlete is perfectly happy to let the dice and its ridiculous cast of characters do most of the work.

But the end result is surprisingly similar.

It’s a kind of fun that doesn’t really come from the game itself. You and your friends bring that to the table. Magical Athlete simply provides the excuse, facilitating the experience by being sufficiently silly and creating just enough outrageous situations to keep the energy going.

Notably, and I think this is where Magical Athlete gets something absolutely right, the game is almost perfectly timed. Four races are exactly what this experience needs. One less and it would feel a little undercooked, one more and I suspect the whole thing would start to wear out its welcome.

It knows what it is, does its little dance and gets off the stage before anyone starts throwing tomatoes.

I honestly can’t tell you that Magical Athlete’s gameplay is “good”, at least not by any conventional measuring stick I can think of. It really isn’t. It’s too simple, too generic and offers far too little control over what happens at the table to be mechanically interesting. In fact, I’m fairly certain that even a game like Sorry! offers more rules and more meaningful decisions than Magical Athlete.

If you were to sit down and assess this game purely on the merits of its mechanics, you’d probably conclude that there isn’t much of a game here at all. I would imagine that for many, this is exactly the sort of reception this one might get.

If for some reason the original Magical Athlete wasn’t enough for you, there is a follow-up coming in the near future that appears to simply triple down on this chaotic racing game concept. Strange that a game I thought I would have no interest in has me seriously considering getting its follow-up. I say this often, but the way tabletop gaming surprises me all the time, even after over a decade of game reviews, is my favorite thing about the hobby.

And yet, here’s the strange thing. It’s actually quite a bit of fun.

There are, however, some important caveats to that statement, and I think understanding them is absolutely critical to getting anything out of Magical Athlete.

First, you want as many people at the table as you can reasonably gather. This is a party game through and through, and I really don’t think you’re going to discover the magical part of Magical Athlete playing with just two or three people. You want five or six. You want a crowded table, plenty of banter, people cheering for their ridiculous little racers and everyone getting worked up over the absurdity of it all.

The more people you have invested in the nonsense, the better the nonsense becomes.

Timing is equally important, perhaps even more so.

Magical Athlete isn’t really a game I’d recommend pulling out on a dedicated game night, at least not when everyone has gathered with the intention of playing some proper board games. You know the sort of evening I’m talking about, when people are ready to sink their teeth into something with a bit of mechanical substance, some interesting decisions and a satisfying strategic challenge.

Magical Athlete is not that game.

Instead, this is something you pull out when you’re hanging out with friends, having a few drinks, everyone’s already laughing and there’s a good, fun energy in the room. It’s the sort of game that works best when nobody is particularly concerned about winning, losing or even playing especially well.

In that environment, Magical Athlete becomes a kind of topper to the evening, a dessert of sorts. Something light, colorful and just ridiculous enough to add another memorable little moment to an already enjoyable gathering.

And I think that’s the secret to this game. It doesn’t really create the party. It joins one that’s already in progress and adds something a little unique and special, like a lover that surprises you in the bedroom. You didn’t expect it, even realize you needed it, but when it arrives, suddenly it becomes the highlight of the evening.

I honestly expected that by the time I reached the gameplay section of this review, I’d be preparing to deliver a fairly negative assessment. On paper, Magical Athlete has almost everything I generally dislike about board games. Its mechanics are simplistic, its decisions are limited and its outcomes are largely dictated by luck. If I were rating this game academically, based purely on reading the rules and assessing the design, there would be very little here to get excited about.

But tabletop gaming doesn’t happen on paper.

It happens around a table, with actual people, and sometimes the experience of playing a game is something entirely different from what its rules might suggest.

The truth is that, so far, every time I’ve pulled out Magical Athlete and actually played it, the room has lit up. People laugh, cheer, complain about their terrible luck and get far more emotionally invested in these ridiculous little races than they have any reasonable right to be.

This picture I think, illustrates the exact moment Magical Athlete should be hitting the table. Yeah, a couple of beers, some good friends, and simply the joy of doing something silly that is in a nutshell, what this game is all about, and I think it’s exactly what it’s going for as a design goal.

And perhaps more importantly, when the game is over, people remember having a good time. They talk about the ridiculous things that happened, and when we get together again, someone inevitably asks if we’re going to play Magical Athlete. The game creates memories, which, I think, is perhaps the greatest compliment you can give a tabletop game in a review.

That, to me, is a pretty compelling argument that something here is working.

It’s unexpected, certainly, but that’s one of the wonderful things about tabletop gaming. Games have this remarkable ability to surprise and delight us in ways that aren’t always easy to explain through an analysis of mechanics, strategy or design.

Sometimes a game is greater than the sum of its parts, even when those parts aren’t particularly impressive to begin with.

And when a game manages to capture a little magic in the box, perhaps trying to dissect exactly how or why it works is missing the point entirely.

Why explain it? If it works… it works…

Replayability and Longevity

Score: christmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_starchristmas_star
Tilt: christmas_star

Pros: Timeless party game appeal with plenty of potential for hilarious, memorable moments. A charming little game that can earn a permanent spot in your collection when played with the right crowd.

Cons: Limited mechanical variety and strategic depth mean replayability depends heavily on the players and occasion. A niche experience that needs the right atmosphere to shine.

The replayability in Magical Athlete comes mostly from the fun memories it creates at the table rather than any mechanical juice or strategic garnish it provides. As such, much of this game’s longevity is going to come down to pulling it out at the right time, with the right people.

Fortunately, that’s actually a pretty easy caveat to work around. As gamers, it’s kind of second nature for us to read the room and know what game is right for the moment. In fact, I think this is something we think about quite a lot. Our gaming libraries are filled with games that, when pulled out with the wrong group at the wrong time, would be complete disasters. Yet, with the right crowd and under the right circumstances, those same games can be absolutely amazing.

I mean, I love Empire of the Sun and Twilight Imperium, but both require a very specific audience. Try introducing either of them to the wrong group at the wrong time and you’re setting yourself up for an unmitigated disaster. That doesn’t make them bad games, it just means there’s a time and place for them.

There is a time and place for every game, and while I think creating a flowchart like this is overkill, I do believe most gamers can relate. This is why a typical gamer has shelves full of games and has to often answer the question, why do you need so many? Trust me, we have our reasons, and this flowchart illustrates it. Magical Athlete has a place here somewhere!

Magical Athlete is no different, even if it sits at the complete opposite end of the gaming spectrum. This is very much a five- or six-player party game. You don’t pull it out on a dedicated game night, you pull it out at a social occasion when you want to inject a bit of ridiculous fun into an already enjoyable evening.

In that sense, I think Magical Athlete has a pretty good shelf life, perhaps even earning itself a permanent residence in your gaming library. It has its niche, certainly, but there’s nothing about the execution of the game that suggests its appeal is going to wear off any faster than any other good party game.

It’s actually a rather timeless little concept, the sort of game you can keep tucked away on your shelf, knowing that when the right occasion comes along, you can pull it out and trust it to stick the landing.

Conclusion

Magical Athlete is not a good game in the traditional sense, at least not by any conventional or analytical assessment of its mechanics. If you’re looking for clever design, meaningful decisions or strategic depth, you’re barking up entirely the wrong tree. Whatever magic this peculiar little game possesses, you’re certainly not going to discover it by reading the rulebook.

But there is a surprise waiting for you in this box.

Despite what your first impressions might suggest, Magical Athlete has charm. It has personality. It has this wonderfully infectious joy injected into it, a sort of natural charisma that somehow manages to transform a painfully mundane gaming mechanic into something genuinely entertaining.

It’s an oddball, a misfit, a wonderfully eccentric little creation that has absolutely no business being as much fun as it is.

And I certainly didn’t see that coming.

When I first read the rules, I honestly thought I was going to hate this game. Quite the opposite of being excited to play it, I was practically preparing my disappointment in advance. Roll a die, move a piece, occasionally do something weird. Oh boy, sign me up!

But somehow, against all expectations, Magical Athlete pulled a complete 180 on me. What began as a rather presumptuous dismissal of a game I thought I had figured out before even playing it turned into a wonderful little discovery. A game that, through sheer personality, charm and an almost inexplicable ability to generate laughter, managed to earn itself a permanent spot on my shelf.

I think Magical Athlete is a fantastic choice for family game night with younger kids, thanks to its simple rules and gloriously wacky characters. It’s a great party game for injecting a bit of madcap lunacy into an evening with friends, and it can even serve as a delightful little palate cleanser during a more serious board game night when everyone needs a break from all that strategic brain-burning.

It’s definitely a niche game, and timing its introduction is important, but I’d argue that’s true of just about every game in our collections. Magical Athlete simply knows what it wants to be, makes absolutely no apologies for it and gets on with the business of being thoroughly ridiculous.

I loved it.

Magical Athlete gets a big recommendation from Gamersdungeon, not because it’s some brilliant feat of game design, but because it reminded me of something that’s surprisingly easy to forget when you’ve spent decades playing, analyzing and reviewing board games.

Sometimes we get so caught up in mechanics, clever systems, strategic depth and all the little things that supposedly make a game good that we forget the most important thing of all.

Fun is fun.

You don’t always have to explain the how or why of it. You don’t have to dissect it, justify it or even fully understand it.

Sometimes all you have to do is enjoy it.

And enjoy it I did!

First Impressions: Trials of Maya (2026)

Check Out Trials Of Maya Crowdfunder (Gamefound)

When this monster-sized box showed up at my house, I was already pretty amped up by the sales pitch. An expandable, card-driven, MOBA-style game? Hello yes! I love MOBA games; god only knows how many hours I burned playing League of Legends, Heroes of Newerth, and DOTA.

Suffice it to say, this was a concept that spoke to me directly. In fact, it’s the sort of game I have been looking for so desperately that, in the absence of its existence, I tried to create one myself. I’m about as close to a target audience for Trials of Maya as you’re ever going to get.

What is a MOB? It stands for Multiplayer Online Battle Arena, a genre of gaming that involves players (typically 5 vs 5) running unique characters from a large roster all with special and unique abilities fighting on a map over a serious of towers and the ulimtate price, the opponents base camp. First team to blow up their oppossitions base camp wins.

League of Legends in particular for me was THE MOBA to play. Like most MOBA’s, it’s about the Champions first and foremost and all the crazy interaction between all their various powers. This is really what I’m hoping Trials of Maya gets close to as a game.

I should fully disclose before we get going here that this First Impression article is based on a single two-player siege mode game. This is not the review; That we will do later, but I felt, given that the crowdfunding for this one is going live next month, there are probably plenty of people out there looking it up.

Trials of Maya is here… I played it, and it’s time to talk about it.

Opening The Box

This box, and everything in it, feels like more than just a game. It’s a work of art, crafted with a clear focus on turning the simple act of discovering a new board game into a unique visual experience. I knew from the outset this wasn’t going to be just a box opening, and Trials of Maya did not disappoint.

Just the art in this game speaks volumes to the design team’s dedication, though I think this is not only expected, but demanded by MOBA fans. Art in MOBA games is part of the allure, so a board game trying to represent this genre would need to do the legwork. Fortunately, Trials of Maya does indeed pass this trial with flying colors.

Everything here feels as though it was created through the lens of an artist. Personal… designed from the heart. The illustrations, graphic design, components, books, colors, and physical presentation have all been tied together into a single piece of work with a singular vision. Combined, they create the sort of presentation most games don’t even strive for, let alone achieve.

There is an included novel that tells a story from the universe in which the game is set (Just getting into that), offering an inside perspective on the setting and theme. There is striking artwork, and a genuine effort to entice through elaborate, if not sometimes overproduced components. Mind you, I’m working with a prototype here. Even the smallest details seem carefully matched to everything around them, creating a unified whole that comes together almost like a painting.

Every detail in Trials of Maya feels like the result of countless hours of contemplation and creativity. It’s not always successful, but you can’t discount the effort here; this game is someone’s baby boy born from blood, sweat, and tears, that much is clear

To give you one particularly strange and wonderful example, the included novel has a cover that is itself a 3D art piece. The game actually comes with a pair of 3D glasses that reveal the full effect of the cover art.

Why? Why would anyone go through the trouble of doing something like that in a board game?

Supporting a board game with a novel is not unprecedented; in fact, we saw exactly this in Syncanite Foundation I reviewed earlier this year, but I find things like this make me giddy, especially if I’m really into a board game. I love exploring a cool new settings.

I think the answer can be found in the particular sort of nostalgia Trials of Maya is trying to evoke. The rise of MOBAs belongs to a generation of gaming that grew up surrounded by loud colors, experimental visual design, and a fascination with 3D entertainment. Movies, games, and advertising were constantly trying to leap out of the screen at us. Even the bright red glasses themselves fit perfectly into the color palette and visual identity of Trials of Maya.

It is nostalgia expressed through art, a kind of unnecessary cherry on top, but it speaks volumes to the love affair the designer/producers of this game have with it.

3d Movies were a bit of a gimmick, and I’m not sure it panned out quite how Hollywood hoped it would, but I remember it like it was yesterday, and it was pretty awesome!

I don’t think everyone will have the same reaction, but if you grew up during the rise of MOBAs and were deeply immersed in gaming culture at the time, there is something about Trials of Maya that may feel oddly familiar.

Yet for all that familiarity, this is certainly not another game drawing exclusively from the familiar well of Western fantasy. The Tolkien-inspired traditions and Appendix N influences that dominate so much of fantasy gaming are largely absent here.

Instead, Trials of Maya has a striking Indo Asian aesthetic, with characters, clothing, architecture, symbolism, and mythology that appear influenced by Indic and broader Asian artistic and cultural traditions. Combined with its science fantasy elements, it gives the world an identity that feels immediately distinct from anything else you will see out there.

I spend a great deal of time reviewing games, reading about games, and as a side effect reviewing artwork. We get all kinds, but for me personally, I love it when art is both really unique and exceptional, while still comfortable and familiar in a way. This definitely has a League of Legends Wukong feel to it and I love that.

I am going on and on here, but I think that is justified. So much effort has gone into the presentation of Trials of Maya that it deserves to be lingered over.

In a word, Trials of Maya is absolutely gorgeous. We are off to a really great start!

Setup and Components

While Trials of Maya is artistically impressive, we have to put the artistry aside for a moment because even in a First Impressions article, my job is to offer the reader a dose of reality. I don’t want to be all hype and no substance. Anyone interested in this game is going to want a breakdown of the game itself.

Eye candy is eye candy. The game is the game.

There is no question in my mind that in order for a modern, crowdfunded board game to do well, it must indeed be eye-candy. That is the visual advertisement, but in the end, once you get a game to the table, the game lives and dies by its gameplay.

My friend and I set aside half a day to sit down with Trials of Maya and play a one-on-one siege game, one of several game modes the system offers. The Siege Mode is, in effect, the base mode of what we think of as a MOBA game. Towers, minions, lanes of sorts, and the push.

Ahead of his arrival, I read through the rulebook and reference material, trying to get a handle on the game, and got everything set up so that we could dive straight in.

The Rulebook is laid out beautifully with very focused areas and clear language. I have read a lot of rulebooks in my day from independent publishers and crowdfunded games, and universally they are usually so bad they are barely usable; I was very pleasantly surprised that the Trials of Maya dev team did some quality, professional work here. It made a huge difference for our experience with the game.

Now, it’s important to mention for a second time that I’m working with a prototype of Trials of Maya. Keep that firmly in mind as a lens through which to view the following comments.

While the components look fantastic laid out on the table, and much of the physical design is exceptionally well conceived, even during setup I could see that Trials of Maya was going to be a fairly fiddly game.

The hexagonal battlefield is very tight, and there is a lot of stuff that goes onto it, leaving surprisingly little room for fat fingers to maneuver. Setup itself was not particularly complicated, albeit it took about 20 minutes. The physical components, while gorgeous through and through, were something of a mixed bag in the usability department, ranging from fantastic to …meh.

The player boards, for example, are really well thought out. Components fit snugly into designated spaces, and everything is organized in a visually accessible way. It was particularly convenient to be able to look across the table and, with a quick glance, understand the board state of my opponent. Critical to executing the game successfully and being fully informed.

I really loved the character cards; everything is well organized, has a clear purpose… every aspect of the tactile design aces the test, and it looks gorgeous to boot!

The cards were similarly successful. The iconography is relatively simple, and we adjusted to it quickly. Most of the cards we encountered during our game were clear, and whenever something was not immediately obvious, there was handy reference material included with the game that made answers easy to find.

My friends and I have all designed a lot of cards for our games over the years, and this is exactly what you want. Nice looking, clear text, clear iconography, and consistency. This is how you make cards for a card game. Well done!

Some of the physical components in this prototype, however, were clumsy.

Several pieces were easy to knock over and awkward to grab, resulting in quite a few frustrating fumbles during play. The stackable chips in particular, used to track the health of minions, while a good idea conceptually, had a tendency to topple over. The various spawn and upgrade markers had similar problems because they stood upright and were rather top-heavy.

You get a better sense of the board from the side here, but there is a lot of three-dimensional stacking here; those plastic chips are feather light, and even a tiny bump can knock a stack over. Don’t get me wrong, I think using chips to track health of units is clever and looks great, but if you’re going to use chips in a game like this where they get handled a lot, they need to have some weight to them like poker chips.

There was also a more practical issue with the battlefield itself. Many components completely covered the hex they occupied, making it difficult to see symbols or terrain features underneath them. Walls and other important battlefield information could effectively disappear once the board became populated. The board really could have been 20% bigger.

None of this is catastrophic, but in a game built around positioning and tactical information, where you’re constantly moving pieces around, physical usability matters.

There is still time before release to tighten some of these components up and, in fact, the designer has expressed a commitment to doing exactly that. Trials of Maya is clearly in the final stages of production preparation, and I would expect that a number of these details will change before the finished game reaches players.

For that reason, I would not personally count these issues against the game at this stage. This is precisely what prototypes are for.

Still, it’s worth mentioning because there is an important distinction here. A game needs to be both beautiful and easy to use. Trials of Maya has unquestionably nailed the first half of that equation. The prototype suggests there is still some work to be done on the second.

With everything finally set up, however, it was time to dive in.

Both my gaming partner and I were excited; I in particular was holding my breath because I desperately want this game to be good.

Gods! I need a good MOBA tabletop game, let this be the one!

Rules, Mechanics and Gameplay

As one might expect, right out of the gate we fumbled around with the rules and got a few things wrong. This is not particularly unusual with a brand new game, especially one that is a bit more complex and comes from an independent publisher clearly willing to experiment with new mechanics and ideas. I only mention it because the game came with a strong solution.

The rulebook was very well written. Whenever we discovered that we had misunderstood something, we were quickly able to find the answer, correct ourselves, and keep going. The reference booklet and reference cards reinforced this, and before long we were playing without needing to constantly stop and consult the rules.

This is big for me because I find universally that most independent crowdfunders have terrible rulebooks; Trials of Maya succeeded where most people fail, and this is such a critical element of getting off on the right foot with a new game. Big kudos to the design team!

After a couple of rounds, Trials of Maya started to come into focus.

We began to see the strategy, understand the rhythm of the game, and recognize how all of its interconnected systems were supposed to work.

The aha moment had arrived. It was time to get down to the business of crushing each other’s souls! We were itching for the action.

My gaming partner and I were pretty focused during the game, so we did not spend much time discussing our opinions while we played. We were too busy trying to successfully navigate our characters around the battlefield, uncover combinations between cards and abilities, manipulate minions, and control important areas of the board as we fought our way toward each other’s towers.

Because that is essentially the game.

Each round you gain energy from cards that slide off your tableau as well as play new cards. You then spend that energy executing actions from the cards in play in your tableau, moving your character, attacking enemies, and triggering various special abilities. Meanwhile, your character develops and becomes increasingly powerful as you complete objectives and gain XP.

In other words, pretty much exactly what you would expect and I hoped from a MOBA board game.

Very much like actual MOBA’s, pushing forward and controlling the forward position is key to the game. You want to be fighting closer to your opponent’s tower so that when an opportunity opens up you’re within striking distance. As such, controlling neutral spawn points is a major point of contention in the game.

This is a card-driven tactical game about fighting with your character and controlled minions, pushing toward the enemy tower and trying to pull off various gambits and shenanigans as you outmaneuver your opponent.

Each character felt genuinely unique, with clearly defined strengths and weaknesses. Some were fast, some excelled at range, and others were built to stand their ground and absorb punishment. There were only four characters available in this prototype, but it was not difficult to imagine another thirty.

There is no question that Trials of Maya feels infinitely expandable in this area, and I suspect that discovering new characters and learning how to exploit their unique abilities is going to be a big part of the long-term appeal of the game. In fact, like a MOBA, I would expect in groups where the game is played often, META’s will form as they would in League of Legends or DOTA, with homebrew tournament rules undoubtedly forming.

The Trials of Maya prototype came with four characters, each with their own deck of cards, abilities, skills, and stats. Even with just four characters, there is plenty to explore mechanically, but you can see how very obviously, more is better! I haven’t mentioned the quality of the sculpts here, mainly because I find pictures tell the story for the most part. I can say that the miniatures in my box were actually a lot nicer and more detailed than the ones depicted in the marketing material. These are very paint-worthy minis

The customizable card decks add another layer to that potential.

You can essentially create your own version of each character by modifying their deck. We did not experiment with deck construction during our first game, choosing instead to use the recommended starting decks, but halfway through the game I already had strong opinions about which cards I wanted to remove and what sorts of cards I would want to replace them with.

That’s a very good sign.

The potential here is exceptional and, more importantly, I would argue the game is already very fun in its current form. There are several other game modes still to explore, and I strongly suspect that a four-player siege game is going to be considerably more chaotic and exciting than our one-on-one match. Though I am deeply concerned about the game’s length. Our two-player game stretched well into the 3rd hour, and while we were new and a slow first game is understandable, I worry that a 4-player game is going to be a pretty extended affair.

I personally thought Trials of Maya succeeded in bringing the MOBA genre to life on the tabletop, though I would argue it felt a bit slow. Perhaps the most accurate description of the experience came from my gaming partner. At the end of the match, he looked up from the board and uttered a sentence that perfectly encapsulated what both of us were thinking.

“This was a really fun game, but it had some jank.”

I completely agree. That statement, however, requires some explanation.

First, I will remind you once again that this is a First Impressions article about a prototype game. After a single play, I would not feel comfortable being held to account for any definitive conclusions about its finer mechanical details; these are gut instincts firing here. We are going to tackle the depth of this game in the review later after having a few more plays under our belts.

Think of what follows less as criticism and more as an advisory observation from two people who have spent an ungodly amount of time designing and playing prototype games ourselves, desperately trying to get the jank out of our own designs.

It’s experience shining through and, perhaps more importantly, an acknowledgement of just how difficult it is to truly streamline a game.

Jank, for lack of a better term, is what happens when a game is clearly on the right track and has a fundamentally good design, but still has mechanics or physical elements that need refinement. It’s a kind of threshold for a game. It’s when a game is so close to its final version that you can taste it, but there are still little pieces of friction getting between the players and the experience, which can turn a fun game into a frustrating one. Typically and perhaps most commonly, Jank causes games to be longer than they should be.

Jank is the demon every game designer eventually has to tango with, but perhaps more problematically, crowdfunded games are famous for leaving the Jank in on release. Something I’m always weary of.

I think that is exactly where Trials of Maya is in this prototype, and I really hope it’s not too late for the designers to address and fine-tune this game further.

Some of the jank comes from the components themselves, as I have already described. The game is simply a bit too fiddly right now, slowing it down and making it feel a bit clumsy.

These strike me as very solvable problems.

In fact, the next time I play Trials of Maya I will probably just use my clay poker chips for tracking minion health, for example, as a solution to chips toppling over all the time. Clay poker chips are designed to stack, they stay put, they are easy to grab, and they are smaller in diameter. In a game where moving stacks of chips around the battlefield is a constant activity, you want this part to be smooth as silk.

Anyone who has ever played poker with plastic, rather than clay poker chips, will instantly know what I’m talking about when I say light plastic chips do not stack and fall over all the time. It’s why in poker you use heavier, clay chips. I can’t even describe how huge of a difference this would make for Trials of Maya.

There was some mechanical jank as well, though this is where I become much more cautious about drawing conclusions after a single game.

Both my partner and I felt that something about the handling of allied minions was still a little off.

During the game, the neutral minions that begin on the battlefield are quickly converted into allied minions controlled by the players. This part we liked, but we soon discovered that stacks of allied minions die quite quickly and, almost immediately, those same minions begin spawning back onto the battlefield.

The result was a revolving game of attrition where minion deaths primary impact on the game was slowing it to a crawl.

Minions were returning as quickly as we could kill them, you really couldn’t “clear the lane” for those familiar with MOBA terminology. Movement is fairly limited for all but the most mobile characters as it is; the battlefield is extremely tight, and the sequence of play allows minions to spawn at the beginning of a player’s turn and then act during that same turn, often in the same turn they died.

As a result, the board state could collapse and rebuild itself in one swift sequence of actions during the same turn. There is little breathing room, in one turn you achieve success, in the very next it’s all undone, and there is not much you could do about it.

This attrition results in the game being a lot less decisive with really heavy attrition and, as a consequence, a lot longer than I think it needs to be.

Something about that rhythm felt off to both of us.

I definitely want to play Trials of Maya a couple more times before making any stronger judgment about it. There may be, in fact, likely are aspects of the minion system that we simply failed to appreciate during our first game, and I suspect a four-player game could reveal considerably more nuance. Not to mention that the custom deck building I think is going to become a key feature of the game on repeated plays. Even after a single game, I felt quite ready to build my own deck.

We were slicing and dicing minions by the handfuls; they were leaving play and returning at breakneck speeds. It was fun at first, but this attrition really slowed the game down to a crawl and extended its overall playtime quite dramatically.

What I had considerably less trouble forming an opinion about was the card play.

I loved the card powers and the mechanic of sliding cards off your tableau to generate energy. There was a clear strategy and rhythm to it. It quickly became clear that every card had subtle benefits and drawbacks. There were cards I desperately wanted to get into play, while others seemed less useful until some unexpected situation or coordinated combos suddenly transformed them into the most important card in my hand.

That was really fun.

Even better was discovering some of the funky shenanigans possible when certain cards and abilities started interacting.

At one point I suddenly realized that a particular combination of cards in play would allow my character to essentially shoot across the entire battlefield, bypass the enemy forces and make a direct assault on my opponent’s tower.

I caused devastating damage in short order and nearly pulled off a win right then and there. That was the first time the game felt responsive, less about attrition and more about action. And in that moment, Trials of Maya did exactly what I wanted it to do; it felt like I had hoped it would.

I think in a way, the overarching jank in Trials of Maya is that it’s too slow most of the time; when the action exploded like that, it was the first time the game felt really good, and I think that is what this game should be. A quick 30-45 knife fight in a phone booth of moves and counter moves, not a slow strategic game of attrition.

For a moment, it felt like a classic League of Legends tower rush. Like a proper MOBA game, and I think that is precisely what this game should be striving for. MOBA’s are not thinking, strategic games, they are action games that require quick thinking and quick decisions.

First Impression Conclusion

I don’t particularly like writing first impression conclusions.

There is a sort of finality implied by the word conclusion when the reality is that I’m only just beginning to explore Trials of Maya. If there is one thing I have learned from reviewing games over the years, it’s that my opinions can change wildly during that process.

I remember playing Lord of the Rings The Card Game for the first time and absolutely hating it. A year later, it held the number one spot on my Top 10 Best Games of All Time list, a position it would hold for nearly a decade.

Never judge a game by the first time you play it, over the years, I have learned this lesson many times over. From Lord of the Rings, the card game that I hated the first time I played and became one of my all time favorite games, to Eclipse that I hailed as the next coming and now I can’t even stand to look at. All games deserve at least 2-3 plays before you judge (says the game doing a First Impressions article after one play!)

I have seen games go the other way too.

The point is that first impressions can be wrong. Sometimes spectacularly so.

After my first game of Trials of Maya, however, there are three things I feel reasonably confident saying.

First, it was fun.

That sounds like an almost insultingly simple observation, but ultimately it is the most important one, and I think the designer would agree; those are magical confidence-building words to the ears of a person who spent half a decade working on a passion project. Trials of Maya is a game I genuinely cannot wait to get back to the table. It’s beautiful, strategic, highly customizable, and filled with possibilities that I have barely begun to explore.

Even with some prototype jank and a few mechanical questions lingering in my mind, when we packed the game away I was already thinking about the next match.

That matters.

Second, I suspect Trials of Maya may be at its best with four players.

Our two-player Siege game occasionally felt a little isolated. With only two heroes running around the much smaller battlefield, it seemed like there was space in the design waiting to be filled. It kind of felt like an introductory game, with depth that simply wasn’t there for us to explore to keep things simple. I’m very curious to see what happens when four heroes are unleashed on the battlefield with custom decks, creating more combinations, more threats, and presumably considerably more chaos.

In fact, before even getting four people together, I’m tempted to try a two-player game in which we each control two heroes just to see how dramatically that changes the experience. I just wonder about the playtime: how long is a 4-player game going to take?

Third, and perhaps most importantly, I think Trials of Maya has layers that we barely touched.

Toward the end of our game, I started catching glimpses of tactical possibilities that simply had not occurred to us during the opening rounds. Movement, positioning, pushing and pulling characters around the battlefield all seemed considerably more important than we initially understood. The relationships between cards, heroes and minions began revealing opportunities for combinations and clever plays that our basic starting decks only hinted at.

Strategy games, especially customizable card games ones usually have a lot of subtle nuance that may not be evident in a first playthrough. I suspect Trials of Maya definitely falls into that category. It definitely requires more exploration.

That is ultimately what excites me most and may also quell my criticisms. Trials of Maya did not leave me feeling like I had figured it out.

It left me feeling like I wanted to figure it out.

Maybe the game is, in fact, much faster once you know what you’re doing. Maybe that feeling of slow-paced attrition was just the impression of a newbie still trying to come to grips with the game’s strategies.

When that enormous box first arrived at my house, Trials of Maya sounded like the sort of game I had been waiting for. An expandable, customizable, card-driven tactical game that attempts to capture the characters, combinations, battlefield positioning, and tower assaults of a MOBA on the tabletop.

After one game, I am not prepared to tell you that Trials of Maya has completely fulfilled that promise.

I am prepared to tell you that I desperately want to play it again.

For a First Impression, I cannot think of a better conclusion than that.